Skip to main content

PC vs Defects Retention Splits

How retention on a contract is split between Practical Completion and the end of the Defects Liability period, how the amounts are calculated, and where the split shows up across Retention Track.

J
Written by James Coulson

In most construction contracts, retention isn't released in one go at the end of the job — it's released in two stages: a portion at Practical Completion, and the remainder at the end of the Defects Liability period. Retention Track models this directly on every contract using a single percentage — the PC Retention Release % — which controls how the total retention withheld is split between the two stages.

In this article we walk you through:

  1. What the PC Retention Release % means

  2. The default 50/50 split

  3. How PC and Defects retention amounts are calculated

  4. Practical Completion Date and Defects End Date

  5. Where you see the PC/Defects split in Retention Track

  6. How retention release dates flow from the split

  7. Changing the split after a contract is created

  8. Common questions

What the PC Retention Release % means

The PC Retention Release % is a single number set on each contract. It tells Retention Track what share of the total retention withheld becomes claimable when the works reach Practical Completion. The remainder is held until the Defects Liability period ends.

A few examples to make this concrete, using a contract with $10,000 of retention withheld:

PC Retention Release %

Claimable at Practical Completion

Claimable at end of Defects

50% (default)

$5,000

$5,000

100%

$10,000

$0

0%

$0

$10,000

60%

$6,000

$4,000

The Defects share is always whatever's left over — you don't set it directly. If the PC share is 60%, the Defects share is automatically 40%.

The default 50/50 split

When you create a new contract, the PC Retention Release % is pre-filled to 50% — i.e. half released at Practical Completion, half at the end of the Defects Liability period. This is the most common arrangement in standard construction contracts in Australia, New Zealand and the UK, so you'll usually leave it as is.

If your contract specifies a different split (for example, a 60/40 or 70/30 release), edit the PC Retention Release % field in the Financials section of the contract form before creating the contract.

How PC and Defects retention amounts are calculated

Retention Track uses two complementary approaches to determine how much retention belongs to each portion:

  • Retention Withheld — pooled across all invoices, manual journals and credit notes, then split using the PC Retention Release %.

  • Retention Released or Used — attributed directly using a tag you assign in Retention Track, so each release/used amount lands in the right portion regardless of the percentage.

Retention Withheld

The split is applied to the total retention withheld on the contract — i.e. the running total of retention accumulated across all invoices, manual journals, and credit notes recorded against the contract.

The formula is:

  • PC Retention Withheld = Total Retention Withheld × PC Retention Release %

  • Defects Retention Withheld = Total Retention Withheld − PC Retention Withheld

For example, if a contract has $12,500 of total retention withheld and the split is set to 50/50:

  • PC portion: $6,250

  • Defects portion: $6,250

Note: For amounts withheld, the split is applied to the pooled total — Retention Track does not store a per-line PC/Defects allocation against retention withheld. As more retention is withheld over time, both portions scale together according to the percentage.

Retention Released or Used

As retention is released back to you — or used (e.g. applied to defect work) — the amount is attributed to one portion only, based on a tag you set in Retention Track at the time the release or use is recorded. There's no percentage split for these amounts; the tag determines where they land in full.

The tagging looks like this in each place:

  • Retention Payments recorded in Retention Track — pick a Receipt Type (Practical Completion or Defects) on the payment form. The full payment counts towards that portion.

  • Xero invoices, credit notes and manual journals — for each eligible line on the retention debtors account, Retention Track lets you assign a label (Released or Used) together with a retention type (Practical Completion or Defects). The full line amount is then attributed to that portion. Eligible lines default to whichever milestone date (PC or Defects End) is soonest in the future at the time of syncing, so most lines arrive already tagged appropriately — you only need to change the tag in edge cases.

The remaining outstanding balance for each portion is therefore:

Outstanding (PC) = PC Withheld − PC Released − PC Used

Outstanding (Defects) = Defects Withheld − Defects Released − Defects Used

For more on recording payments and how they affect the balance, see Recording and Deleting Retention Payments.

Practical Completion Date and Defects End Date

Each contract carries two milestone dates that, together with the split, drive when retention becomes claimable:

  • Practical Completion Date — the date the works are expected to reach Practical Completion. The PC portion of retention is claimable from this date onwards.

  • Defects End Date — the date the Defects Liability period ends. The Defects portion of retention is claimable from this date onwards.

Both dates are set on the contract form in the Financials section, and can be edited later from the contract page.

Note: When you change the Practical Completion Date on a new contract, Retention Track automatically advances the Defects End Date to 12 months later. Once you edit the Defects End Date manually, that auto-advance stops and the two dates can be set independently. This is just a convenience for the most common 12-month defects period — if your contract specifies a different length, edit the Defects End Date afterwards.

Where you see the PC/Defects split in Retention Track

The PC/Defects split surfaces in three main places.

Contract overview

Open any contract from the Contracts menu in the left sidebar, then look at the Retentions Breakdown card on the contract overview tab. The split appears in two ways:

  • A PC: X% | Defects: Y% badge in the top-right corner of the card shows the configured split.

  • Next to the Total Retentions Withheld line, hover the small info icon to see the amount broken out into PC and Defects portions.

This gives you an at-a-glance view of how much retention is allocated to each stage, alongside the total amounts withheld and released.

Contractor contracts export

From the Contractors menu, open a contractor and click Export Contracts (or download the outstanding balances report). The Excel spreadsheet now includes five extra columns alongside each contract's outstanding balance:

  • PC Date — the contract's Practical Completion Date.

  • PC Amount — the outstanding PC retention balance, exclusive of sales tax.

  • Defects Date — the contract's Defects End Date.

  • Defects Amount — the outstanding Defects retention balance, exclusive of sales tax.

  • Security — the name of any linked retention trust account or security, or N/A if none.

A totals row at the bottom sums each column so you can see, in one view, how much retention is sitting in each stage across all of a contractor's contracts.

Dashboard

On the workspace dashboard, the Top Outstanding Retention Holdings chart aggregates each contractor's PC and Defects outstanding balances into a single total per contractor. The chart itself shows the combined figure, but the underlying data is sourced from the PC/Defects split so you can drill into each contractor to see how the total breaks down.

How retention release dates flow from the split

Retention Track uses the PC/Defects split together with the two milestone dates to plan upcoming payment claims:

  1. When the Practical Completion Date falls within the upcoming-claims window, Retention Track surfaces the PC portion of the outstanding retention balance as an upcoming claim, with the PC Date as its release date.

  2. When the Defects End Date falls within the upcoming-claims window, Retention Track surfaces the Defects portion as a separate upcoming claim, with the Defects End Date as its release date.

  3. Each portion is claimed independently — you can issue a Practical Completion claim months before the Defects portion becomes due, and Retention Track tracks the two through their own claim and payment records.

Once a claim is created for a portion, the Receipt Type on any retention payments recorded against it (Practical Completion or Defects) is automatically aligned to the claim's retention type. See Creating a Payment Claim for the full claiming flow.

Changing the split after a contract is created

You can update the PC Retention Release % at any time from the contract's edit page:

  1. Open the contract from the Contracts menu in the left sidebar.

  2. Click Edit Contract at the top of the contract page.

  3. Update the PC Retention Release % field in the Financials section.

  4. Click Save to apply the change.

The new percentage applies immediately to the total retention withheld on the contract — the Retentions Breakdown badge, the tooltip amounts, and any upcoming-claims figures update straight away.

Note: Changing the split affects how the pooled withheld retention is allocated, but it does not re-tag amounts already released or used — those stay attributed to whichever portion they were tagged against. If you change the split after recording releases, the outstanding balances on each portion will reflect both the new split and the existing tagged attributions.

Common questions

Can I set a different PC/Defects split per invoice?

No — the headline PC Retention Release % is set once per contract and applied to the contract's pooled withheld retention. Individual released or used amounts can be tagged Practical Completion or Defects on a per-line basis, but you can't override the withheld split for a specific invoice. If different invoices on the same contract genuinely need different release timing, the cleanest approach is usually to set up separate contracts.

Can I set the split to 100% PC or 100% Defects?

Yes. Setting it to 100% means the entire withheld retention is claimable at Practical Completion; setting it to 0% means the entire withheld retention is claimable only at the end of the Defects Liability period. Either is fine if that's what your contract actually specifies.

What if I haven't set a Practical Completion Date or Defects End Date yet?

The split is still calculated and the amounts still show on the contract overview and contractor export. The only thing that won't happen is the corresponding upcoming claim being surfaced — Retention Track needs the relevant date in order to plan a claim. You can add or update either date at any time.

Does Xero know about the PC/Defects split?

No — the PC/Defects classification lives entirely within Retention Track. Xero itself doesn't carry a PC or Defects tag on invoice lines, credit notes or manual journal lines. Instead, for each eligible release/used line on the retention debtors account, you assign a label (Released or Used) and a retention type (Practical Completion or Defects) directly in Retention Track. The withheld portion of those documents stays untagged and is split using the contract's PC Retention Release %. For more on how this works for credit notes specifically, see Creating a Xero Credit Note.

Are the PC and Defects amounts shown inclusive or exclusive of sales tax?

The amounts on the contract overview follow your workspace's display preference — most workspaces show retention exclusive of sales tax (GST/VAT). The contractor contracts Excel export always shows the amounts exclusive of sales tax. Internally, the split is calculated on both the exclusive and inclusive figures so the totals always reconcile.

Did this answer your question?